External AI Request Template — ECC Research Atlas Paper Processing
Use this prompt when giving a paper PDF to another AI and asking it to prepare materials for the ECC Research Atlas.
Request
첨부한 논문 PDF를 읽고, ECC Research Atlas에 넣을 수 있도록 아래 표준 양식으로 정리해줘.
Critical Atlas principle
The ECC Research Atlas is book-anchored.
- Primary anchor: Victor C. Li, Engineered Cementitious Composites (ECC): Bendable Concrete for Sustainable and Resilient Infrastructure, Springer, 2019. DOI:
10.1007/978-3-662-58438-5. - Supporting / verification layer: papers that verify, deepen, or historically trace the book's claims.
- Extension layer: latest research beyond the book, including self-healing, self-sensing, sustainability, extreme-ductility ECC, high-strength/high-ductility ECC, applications, AI/DIC/XCT, etc.
- Lab connection: user-lab-specific positioning is a later phase. Do not infer or invent lab connections.
This paper should be classified as either:
supporting: supports or verifies claims already synthesized in Victor Li's book.extension: extends the book with later or more specialized research.lab_connection_candidate: potentially relevant to the user's lab, but do not make lab-position claims unless explicitly supported.
Non-negotiable rules
- Use only what is in the PDF. Do not invent facts, figures, pages, equations, DOI, or results.
- If page / figure / table / equation numbers are unclear, write
needs_check. - If OCR or extraction is uncertain, mark
needs_ocr_check. - Long quotations are not needed. Use short evidence excerpts only.
- Distinguish direct tensile strain capacity from flexural ductility. Do not call a material extreme-ductility ECC unless direct tensile evidence supports it.
- Distinguish high compressive strength from high tensile ductility. High strength alone is not extreme ductility.
- Keep Victor Li 2019 book as the primary anchor. This paper is supporting or extension evidence only.
- Output in Markdown.
- Full-text extraction may be done with Python or OCR tools, but the source note, paper card, Atlas-node mapping, and claim-evidence rows must be created by AI reasoning after reading the paper.
Deliverable 1 — Extracted Full Text
You may create the full-text extraction using Python, OCR, built-in PDF tools, or any other reliable extraction method. This deliverable can be produced mechanically.
However, all later deliverables must be written by you after reading and reasoning over the paper, not merely generated by a script. In particular, the source note, paper card, claim-evidence candidates, Atlas node links, limitations, and relationship to Victor Li's book must reflect your own understanding of the PDF content.
Create a full-text extraction file in this format.
Recommended filename:
[author-year-short-title]_full_text.md
Template:
# Full Text Extracted: [PDF filename]
**Source Document**: `[PDF filename]`
**Total Pages**: [number]
**Extraction Method**: [method/tool used]
**Extraction Quality**: good / partial / poor / needs_ocr_check
---
## Page 1
[Extracted text]
---
## Page 2
[Extracted text]
---
[Continue for all pages]
If the PDF has tables or equations that do not extract cleanly, add:
## Extraction issues
- Page X: equation/table/figure caption unclear; needs_check.
Important: use the extracted text only as input
After extraction, read the paper and prepare the following deliverables yourself. Do not simply fill the templates with keyword matches. The next deliverables require expert judgment:
- identify the paper's actual contribution;
- decide whether it is supporting or extension evidence;
- connect it to Victor Li's book chapter structure;
- select appropriate Atlas nodes;
- formulate claim-evidence rows;
- mark uncertainty conservatively.
Deliverable 2 — Source Note
Create a source note in the following exact structure.
Recommended filename:
[author-year-short-title]_source_note.md
Template:
---
title: ""
authors: ""
year:
journal: ""
volume: ""
issue: ""
pages: ""
doi: ""
pdf_filename: ""
source_collection: "external"
atlas_layer: "supporting | extension | lab_connection_candidate"
related_book_chapter: "Chapter N: title"
related_atlas_nodes:
- "02_concepts/..."
- "04_material_systems/..."
- "05_experiments/..."
verification_status: "source_note_seed"
---
# [Paper Title]
## One-line Summary
[One sentence summary of the paper.]
## 1. Document Information
- **Title**:
- **Authors**:
- **Year**:
- **Journal / Conference**:
- **Volume / Issue / Pages**:
- **DOI**:
- **PDF filename**:
- **Related Victor Li book chapter**:
- **Atlas layer**: supporting / extension / lab_connection_candidate
## 2. Why this paper matters for the Atlas
- [Why the paper is useful for ECC Research Atlas.]
- [Which Victor Li book chapter or claim it supports or extends.]
- [Whether it belongs to self-healing, self-sensing, sustainability, extreme ductility, applications, durability, etc.]
## 3. Key Contributions
- [Contribution 1]
- [Contribution 2]
- [Contribution 3]
## 4. Methodology
- **Material system**:
- **Binder / matrix**:
- **Fiber type and volume**:
- **Specimen geometry**:
- **Curing / age**:
- **Test methods**:
- **Modeling / analysis method**:
- **Imaging / characterization method**:
Use `not reported` when a field is absent.
## 5. Key Results
List results with page / figure / table if directly visible.
- **Tensile strain capacity**: [value + page/figure/table or needs_check]
- **Tensile strength**: [value + source]
- **Compressive strength**: [value + source]
- **Crack width / spacing**: [value + source]
- **Durability / transport result**: [value + source]
- **Self-healing / sensing / functional result**: [value + source]
- **Other key result**:
## 6. Atlas Node Links
Choose all relevant nodes. Add new node candidates if needed.
### Existing node candidates
- `02_concepts/strain_hardening_criteria.md`
- `02_concepts/fiber_bridging_law.md`
- `02_concepts/flaw_design.md`
- `02_concepts/fiber_dispersion.md`
- `02_concepts/processing_rheology.md`
- `02_concepts/interface_properties.md`
- `02_concepts/extreme_ductility_ecc.md`
- `02_concepts/sustainability.md`
- `02_concepts/durability.md`
- `02_concepts/transport_properties.md`
- `02_concepts/self_healing_mechanisms.md`
- `02_concepts/self_healing_robustness.md`
- `02_concepts/piezoresistivity.md`
- `02_concepts/electrical_impedance_tomography.md`
- `02_concepts/photocatalytic_function.md`
- `02_concepts/phase_change_materials.md`
- `02_concepts/smart_infrastructure.md`
- `04_material_systems/green_ecc.md`
- `04_material_systems/self_healing_ecc.md`
- `04_material_systems/self_sensing_ecc.md`
- `04_material_systems/thermal_adaptive_ecc.md`
- `04_material_systems/photocatalytic_ecc.md`
- `05_experiments/direct_tensile_test.md`
- `05_experiments/crack_width_distribution.md`
### Selected links for this paper
- `[node path]` — [reason]
- `[node path]` — [reason]
### New node candidates, if any
- `[proposed_node_name]` — [why needed]
## 7. Claim-Evidence Candidates
| claim_id | Atlas node | Claim | Evidence excerpt | Page/Section | Figure/Table/Equation | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | | | | | | seed / verified_from_pdf / needs_check |
| C2 | | | | | | seed / verified_from_pdf / needs_check |
| C3 | | | | | | seed / verified_from_pdf / needs_check |
Status definitions:
- `verified_from_pdf`: directly checked in the PDF.
- `seed`: plausible from extracted text but not fully checked.
- `needs_check`: page/figure/table/equation/number uncertain.
- `needs_ocr_check`: OCR/extraction may be wrong.
## 8. Relationship to Victor Li 2019 Book
- **Book chapter extended or supported**:
- **Book claim supported**:
- **How this paper extends the book**:
- **Does it change or challenge the book framing?** yes / no / unclear
- **Atlas role**:
- supporting evidence
- latest extension
- mechanism refinement
- application validation
- lab-connection candidate
## 9. Limitations and Cautions
- [Limitation 1]
- [Limitation 2]
- [What should NOT be overclaimed in the Atlas]
## 10. Keywords / Glossary
- **Term**: definition
- **Term**: definition
Deliverable 3 — Paper Card Draft
Create a paper card draft in this format.
Recommended filename:
[author-year-short-title]_paper_card.md
Template:
# [Author Year] — [Short Title]
## Citation
[Authors] ([Year]). [Title]. *[Journal]*, [volume(issue)], [pages].
- DOI: [DOI or needs_check]
- Atlas layer: supporting / extension / lab_connection_candidate
- Related Victor Li book chapter: [Chapter]
- Source PDF: `[PDF filename]`
- Extracted text: `[full_text_filename]`
- Source note: `[source_note_filename]`
## Why this paper matters
[Short explanation of role in the Atlas.]
## Main contribution
- [Contribution 1]
- [Contribution 2]
- [Contribution 3]
## Evidence summary
- [Evidence 1, with page/figure/table if available]
- [Evidence 2]
- [Evidence 3]
## Linked Atlas nodes
- `02_concepts/...`
- `04_material_systems/...`
- `05_experiments/...`
## Relationship to Victor Li book
- Primary book anchor remains Victor Li 2019.
- This paper supports / extends Chapter [N] by [short explanation].
## Claim-evidence rows to add
| Atlas node | Claim | Evidence summary | Page/Figure/Table | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| | | | | |
## Verification status
- PDF preserved: no
- Text extracted: yes / partial / no
- DOI verified: yes / no / needs_check
- Page/figure/table verified: yes / no / partial
- Claim-evidence matrix ready: yes / no / partial
## Cautions
- [Do not overclaim X]
- [Needs check Y]
Deliverable 4 — Claim-Evidence CSV Rows
Also provide suggested CSV rows in Markdown table form.
Use these columns:
paper_id,
paper_card,
year,
atlas_layer,
book_chapter_anchor,
atlas_node,
atlas_file,
claim,
evidence_type,
evidence_summary,
source_note,
full_text_path,
page_or_section,
figure_table_equation,
status,
notes
Template:
| paper_id | paper_card | year | atlas_layer | book_chapter_anchor | atlas_node | atlas_file | claim | evidence_type | evidence_summary | source_note | full_text_path | page_or_section | figure_table_equation | status | notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| seed / verified_from_pdf / needs_check |
Special classification guidance
If the paper is about extreme / ultra ductility
Classify under:
atlas_layer: extension
related_atlas_nodes:
- 02_concepts/extreme_ductility_ecc.md
- 02_concepts/strain_hardening_criteria.md
- 05_experiments/direct_tensile_test.md
Check carefully:
- Is ductility measured by direct uniaxial tension?
- What is the tensile strain capacity?
- Are multiple cracks shown?
- Is crack width controlled?
- Is it high compressive strength, high tensile ductility, or both?
If the paper is about sustainable ECC
Classify under:
atlas_layer: extension
related_atlas_nodes:
- 02_concepts/sustainability.md
- 04_material_systems/green_ecc.md
- 02_concepts/life_cycle_analysis.md
Check:
- Is sustainability from lower embodied carbon, longer service life, LCA, alternative binder, recycled fiber, or reduced repair?
- Does the material retain ECC ductility?
If the paper is about Chapter 10 multifunctional ECC
Classify under:
atlas_layer: extension
related_book_chapter: Chapter 10
Choose nodes:
- self-healing:
02_concepts/self_healing_mechanisms.md,04_material_systems/self_healing_ecc.md - self-sensing:
04_material_systems/self_sensing_ecc.md,02_concepts/piezoresistivity.md - EIT:
02_concepts/electrical_impedance_tomography.md - thermal/PCM:
02_concepts/phase_change_materials.md,04_material_systems/thermal_adaptive_ecc.md - photocatalytic:
02_concepts/photocatalytic_function.md,04_material_systems/photocatalytic_ecc.md
Final output requested
Please output:
- Full extracted text Markdown. This may be produced by Python/OCR/PDF tooling.
- Source note Markdown. This must be written by you after reading the paper.
- Paper card Markdown. This must be written by you after reading the paper.
- Claim-evidence candidate rows. These must be formulated by you and grounded in the PDF.
- A short list of uncertainties /
needs_checkitems.
Do not summarize only. Produce the actual reusable Markdown content. Do not offload the source note, paper card, or claim-evidence reasoning to a script; scripts may assist extraction and searching only.