Claim-Evidence Matrix Classification Summary
- Date: 2026-08-18
- Scope: extreme ductility, sustainable/green ECC, and Bang Yeon Lee lab publication claim-evidence matrices.
Added columns
mechanism_categorymaterial_systemfiber_typebinder_typetest_methodkey_metriclab_relevanceclaim_strengthverification_levelpriority_for_synthesis
Updated files
07_visualization/extreme_ductility_extension_claim_evidence_matrix.csv
- Backup:
07_visualization/extreme_ductility_extension_claim_evidence_matrix_backup_2026-08-18_pre_classification.csv - Rows classified: 136
Mechanism category, first-label counts:
- strain_hardening_criteria: 49
- fiber_bridging: 28
- crack_width_control: 22
- interface_tailoring: 12
- flaw_design: 12
- self_healing: 6
- transport_durability: 4
- fiber_dispersion: 3
Material system, first-label counts:
- UHP-ECC: 38
- seawater_sea_sand_ECC: 24
- ECC/SHCC_general: 21
- EGC: 17
- AAS-ECC: 11
- recycled_selvage_ECC: 11
- PE-ECC: 7
- PVA-ECC: 6
- lightweight_ECC: 1
Priority counts:
- high: 136
Verification counts:
- verified_from_pdf: 136
07_visualization/sustainable_ecc_extension_claim_evidence_matrix.csv
- Backup:
07_visualization/sustainable_ecc_extension_claim_evidence_matrix_backup_2026-08-18_pre_classification.csv - Rows classified: 271
Mechanism category, first-label counts:
- strain_hardening_criteria: 81
- sustainability_lca: 65
- flaw_design: 44
- interface_tailoring: 21
- fiber_bridging: 18
- crack_width_control: 18
- self_healing: 12
- transport_durability: 6
- fiber_dispersion: 6
Material system, first-label counts:
- EGC: 138
- AAS-ECC: 41
- ECC/SHCC_general: 39
- rubberized_ECC: 15
- UHP-ECC: 13
- PVA-ECC: 8
- LC3-ECC: 7
- recycled_selvage_ECC: 5
- seawater_sea_sand_ECC: 3
- PP-ECC: 2
Priority counts:
- high: 204
- medium: 66
- low: 1
Verification counts:
- verified_from_source_note_pending_user_pdf: 260
- verified_from_fulltext: 11
07_visualization/by_lee_lab_publications_claim_evidence_matrix.csv
- Backup:
07_visualization/by_lee_lab_publications_claim_evidence_matrix_backup_2026-08-18_pre_classification.csv - Rows classified: 134
Mechanism category, first-label counts:
- self_healing: 36
- interface_tailoring: 22
- crack_width_control: 20
- fiber_bridging: 17
- strain_hardening_criteria: 14
- flaw_design: 14
- sustainability_lca: 7
- fiber_dispersion: 4
Material system, first-label counts:
- EGC: 73
- ECC/SHCC_general: 21
- recycled_selvage_ECC: 16
- UHP-ECC: 14
- PVA-ECC: 8
- PE-ECC: 1
- AAS-ECC: 1
Priority counts:
- high: 134
Verification counts:
- verified_from_source_note_pending_user_pdf: 134
Notes
- Classification was produced by source-grounded heuristic parsing of claim text, evidence summaries, titles, atlas nodes, and source metadata.
- The new columns are intended for filtering and first-pass synthesis, not for replacing detailed human reading of each source note.
- Rows with
verified_from_source_note_pending_user_pdfshould be revisited after original PDFs are supplied and matched. - Extreme ductility rows retain PDF-based verification status already recorded by the user.