Graph Promotion Validation Report

Pass: Foundational paper graph — concept node creation + edge promotion.

Concept nodes created

Under 02_concepts/:

interface_properties.md
surface_treatment.md
matrix_micro_spalling.md
cook_gordon_effect.md
two_way_debonding.md

Each file includes source basis, core idea, role in ECC micromechanics, key parameters (where applicable), linked nodes, and evidence status with needs verification markers where appropriate.

Edges promoted (Group A, status flipped candidate → confirmed)

All 9 rows from section A of foundational_paper_graph_edge_promotion_plan.md were found in 07_visualization/full_graph_candidate_edges.csv and safely promoted. Evidence paper card references were appended to the existing notes column without breaking CSV structure.

#	Source	Target	Relation	Status
1	micromechanics_based_design	fiber_bridging_law	uses	promoted
2	strain_hardening_criteria	fiber_bridging_law	requires	promoted
3	fiber_bridging_law	distributed_microcracking	controls	promoted
4	strain_hardening_criteria	distributed_microcracking	enables	promoted
5	strain_hardening_criteria	direct_tensile_test	measured_by	promoted
6	direct_tensile_test	strain_hardening_criteria	measures	promoted
7	direct_tensile_test	crack_width_distribution	observes	promoted
8	distributed_microcracking	crack_width_distribution	characterized_by	promoted
9	crack_width_distribution	transport_properties	reduces	promoted

Deferred edges appended (Group B, new rows now enabled)

All 7 rows from section B were appended to full_graph_candidate_edges.csv with status = confirmed (each supported directly by the referenced paper card).

#	Source	Target	Relation	Evidence
B1	interface_properties	fiber_bridging_law	inputs_to	redon_2001; lin_li_1997
B2	interface_properties	strain_hardening_criteria	affects	redon_2001; li_2002
B3	surface_treatment	interface_properties	modifies	redon_2001; li_wang_wu_2001; li_2002
B4	matrix_micro_spalling	fiber_bridging_law	affects	yang_2008
B5	cook_gordon_effect	fiber_bridging_law	affects	yang_2008
B6	two_way_debonding	fiber_bridging_law	affects	yang_2008
B7	scale_linkage	micromechanics_based_design	supports	yang_2008; li_wang_2006

Rows not found / not promoted

None. All 9 Group A rows were found exactly.

Files modified

Added: 02_concepts/interface_properties.md
Added: 02_concepts/surface_treatment.md
Added: 02_concepts/matrix_micro_spalling.md
Added: 02_concepts/cook_gordon_effect.md
Added: 02_concepts/two_way_debonding.md
Edited: 07_visualization/cross_link_map.md (added Interface tailoring subnodes and Fiber-bridging constitutive law subnodes under Micromechanics core)
Edited: 07_visualization/full_graph_candidate_edges.csv (9 status flips + notes evidence; 7 new rows appended)
Added: 07_visualization/full_graph_foundational.json
Added: 07_visualization/full_graph_foundational.md
Added: 07_visualization/graph_promotion_validation_report.md

Verification checks

CSV parses cleanly: 81 rows total (1 header + 80 data), all rows have 7 columns (verified with csv.reader).
Five new concept node files exist under 02_concepts/.
cross_link_map.md references the five new node names under Micromechanics core.
full_graph_foundational.json is valid JSON.
No files under 00_sources/foundational_papers/originals/, 00_sources/foundational_papers/extracted_text/, or 06_lab_position/ were touched.

Blockers

Quantitative values (G_d, τ0, β; oil-coating dose; exact σ(δ) analytical form; exact crack widths in the 60 μm range; DOI; page/figure/equation numbers) remain needs verification in the underlying paper cards. This blocks any claim that requires exact numbers, but does not block the qualitative graph relations promoted here.

Recommended next task

Claim-evidence matrix pass: for each confirmed edge, produce a claim-evidence row that cites the exact source note section and, where possible, the exact page/figure/equation number from the original PDF (resolving the outstanding needs verification items on the foundational paper cards).
Follow-up promotion pass for remaining candidate edges tied to flaw_design, fiber_dispersion, tension_stiffening, and long_term_strain_capacity once the corresponding paper cards are added.